65ADDEmissions and carbon

Additionality

Additionality means an emission cut or removal would not have happened without the money from selling carbon credits or the buyer's intervention.

Also called: additional, additionality test, financial additionality

Raw materialsLand, forests, mines, crops
SuppliersWhat a company buys
CompanyIts own operations and reporting
CustomersWhat it sells and how it is used
End of lifeDisposal, recycling, removals
Capital · banks and investors funding the chain · applies here

What it means for reporting teams

Additionality is the question at the heart of carbon credits: would this project have gone ahead anyway? If a wind farm was already profitable, or a forest was never at risk, selling credits for it does not change the atmosphere. Only additional reductions or removals compensate for emissions elsewhere.

Projects show additionality through tests set by their crediting programme: that the activity goes beyond legal requirements, that it would not be financially viable without credit revenue, or that it faces barriers credits help overcome. The ICVCM treats additionality as one of its Core Carbon Principles and assesses whether methodologies meet it.

The same idea applies to renewable electricity, where buyers ask whether a contract brings new capacity onto the grid. Sustainability and procurement teams should keep the additionality case for each credit or contract on file. Credit rating and registry tools help, but the buyer is still responsible for the claim it makes.

Rules and standards

Rule or bodyWho it coversWhat it asks for
ICVCM Core Carbon PrinciplesCarbon crediting programmes and methodologiesMitigation must be additional, and the CCP label goes only to approved methodologies.
Crediting programme rulesProject developersRegulatory surplus and financial or barrier tests set by each programme.
EU carbon removals certificationRemoval and carbon farming projects seeking EU certificationAdditionality as one of the quality criteria.

Common tests

Regulatory surplusThe activity goes beyond what law already requires.
Investment testThe project is not viable without credit revenue.
Barrier testCredits help overcome technical or market barriers.
Common practiceThe activity is not already widespread in the region.
Back to the ESG Glossary Table